Cleveland’s Automated Photo Enforcement Program and appeals process to continue

The City of Cleveland Automated Photo Enforcement Program is continuing and individuals who wish to appeal violation notices they receive will be able to have a hearing on the matter. This announcement comes after a recent Eighth District Appeals Court decision in Jodka v. Cleveland caused the City to temporarily suspend the hearings.

“Traffic cameras in Cleveland are influencing driver behavior and promoting safe driving,” said Barbara Langhenry, Director of Law. “But it is important to us that citizens who receive civil violation notices through the program have an avenue for appeal. Our ordinance provides for that process through the Photo Safety Division of the Municipal Clerk’s Office.”

The recent Eighth District Appeals Court decision in Jodka v. Cleveland established the Plaintiff had no standing to proceed with the claims in his lawsuit. It also included language that discussed the Court’s view of the constitutionality of the appeals process, but it does not bar the City from operating its traffic camera program and proceeding with the established appeal process in the Municipal Clerk’s office.  Civil traffic camera appeal hearings under Cleveland Codified Ordinance 413.031 will again be scheduled.

Instructions for Citizens

  • If you receive a violation notice through the traffic camera program and do not wish to appeal, follow the instructions on the notice of violation for making payment.
  • If you were previously notified that your scheduled hearing had been delayed, you will receive notification of a new hearing date.
  • If you had received a notice of a camera enforced violation and had a deadline for timely responding to the violation notice between January 23 and today, you may file an appeal within 21 calendar days of this announcement.
  • All appeals will be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.

The City continues to evaluate its appeal process to determine whether another process may be implemented to address the concerns expressed by the Appeals Court. Finally, the City of Cleveland will continue to monitor court action on this matter, as the Plaintiff (Jodka) has asked the Appeals Court to reconsider its opinion.

About Daniel Williams

City of Cleveland, Ohio, Director of Media Relations

4 thoughts on “Cleveland’s Automated Photo Enforcement Program and appeals process to continue

  1. The problem with these cameras is they present a distorted and incomplete view of the scene. A lot of the time they will flag an innocent vehicle where if a policeman were sitting there watching would not take any action.

    Where we need cameras, (and much more police surveillance), is on the freeways, especially during rush hour. People are driving faster, crazier, and more incompetent lately especially when they know the city can’t afford traffic police to be out there!

  2. this is straight up stealing the city, mayor and council is allowing despite court rulings that prove this is an illegal and unconstitutional money grab.

  3. #thisiscleveland So it looks like our wonderful city lost a case in court concerning the legality of all the speed trap cameras they are putting up. Their answer to being told they are illegal? “The City of Cleveland Automated Photo Enforcement Program is continuing and individuals who wish to appeal violation notices they receive will be able to have a hearing on the matter.” If you want to appeal your legal ticket, you will have to pay the city court fees to do so. Speeding is wrong, running red lights are wrong, but so is breaking the law whille enforcing those rules. If the cameras are truly to a safety aid, then police officers should be more visible, patrolling more, making their presence known. Has anyone seen more police presence since the cameras have been installed?

  4. I was given a ticket for going through a school zone while driving 24 mph at 10 am. No flashing signs or indicators were present, and i was not driving in the area right before or after school was in session. So now I drive 20 mph everywhere in Cleveland. I hope I’m promoting enough safety now.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s